Alternative characterizations of the proportional solution for nonconvex bargaining problems with claims
نویسندگان
چکیده
We provide three alternative characterizations of the proportional solution defined on compact and comprehensive bargaining problems with claims that are not necessarily convex. One characterization result is obtained by using, together with other standard axioms, two solidarity axioms. Another characterization theorem shows that the single-valuedness axiom is dispensable even within the class of nonconvex problems if the standard symmetry axiom is imposed. J.E.L. codes: C78, D60, D70.
منابع مشابه
Alternative characterizations of three bargaining solutions for nonconvex problems
This paper studies compact and comprehensive bargaining problems for n players and axiomatically characterize the extensions of the three classical bargaining solutions to nonconvex bargaining problems: the Nash solution, the egalitarian solution and the Kalai-Smorodinsky solution. Our characterizing axioms are various extensions of Nash’s original axioms. ∗ We are grateful to the referee and t...
متن کاملDividing Justly in Bargaining Problems with Claims - Normative Judgments and Actual Negotiations
Theoretical research on claims problems has concentrated on normative properties and axiomatizations of solution concepts. We complement these analyses by empirical evidence on the predictability of three classical solution concepts in a bankruptcy problem. We examine both people’s impartial normative evaluations as well as their actual negotiation behavior in a bargaining with claims environme...
متن کاملAxiomatic Foundations for Compromise Theory†
We provide a characterization of the symmetric and weighted versions of the Euclidean compromise solution for multiobjective optimization problems first proposed by P.L.Yu. These solutions minimize a measure of the distance between a feasible set and the utopia point of that set, and are closely related to solutions that have been proposed in the bargaining with claims literature. We provide ne...
متن کاملOn the Relevance of Alternatives in Bargaining: Average Alternative Solutions
We compare bargaining solutions in terms of the relevance of alternatives. We show that most well-known bargaining solutions do not use all the alternatives, but there are numerous bargaining solutions that do. We introduce a new class of bargaining solutions called ``average alternative solutions'', characterize them, and show that the Nash solution and the Kalai-Smorodinsky solution are limit...
متن کاملAn Efficient Neurodynamic Scheme for Solving a Class of Nonconvex Nonlinear Optimization Problems
By p-power (or partial p-power) transformation, the Lagrangian function in nonconvex optimization problem becomes locally convex. In this paper, we present a neural network based on an NCP function for solving the nonconvex optimization problem. An important feature of this neural network is the one-to-one correspondence between its equilibria and KKT points of the nonconvex optimizatio...
متن کامل